Home title fraud, also known as home title theft, is a serious real estate scam where criminals steal the title of your home and transfer it into their name without your knowledge. Once they control the title, they can use it to commit further crimes, such as selling the property, taking out loans, or using it as collateral. While this type of fraud is rare, its financial consequences can be devastating for homeowners.

The good news? You can take steps to protect yourself by recognizing the warning signs and understanding how to respond if you suspect home title fraud.

How Does Home Title Fraud Happen?

Home title fraud often begins with identity theft. Criminals may steal your Social Security number or other private information to forge documents like quitclaim deeds or warranty deeds. They then file these fraudulent documents with local authorities, such as your town clerk, to transfer the property into their name—all without your knowledge.

Once fraudsters gain control of your home title, they can:

• Use it as collateral for new loans, such as second mortgages or home equity lines of credit (HELOCs).
• Sell the home illegally.
• Rent the property to unsuspecting tenants as part of a scam.

In extreme cases, this fraud can lead to foreclosure or even the illegal sale of your home.

How Common Is Home Title Fraud?

While home title fraud is not widespread, it is growing. According to the FBI’s 2023 Internet Crime Report, real estate-related crimes, including title fraud, caused losses exceeding $145 million in 2023. Although these cases represent a small percentage of overall complaints, the impact on victims can be severe.

Most real estate transactions involve checks and balances, such as identity verification by lenders and title companies, which make title fraud difficult. However, certain situations, like vacant properties or homes owned by seniors, may be more vulnerable to fraud. The FBI and state agencies have issued warnings about an increase in fraudulent property transactions involving vacant land and rental scams.

Warning Signs of Home Title Fraud

Home title fraud can be challenging to detect, but staying alert can help you catch potential issues early. Watch for these warning signs:

1. Unexpected Loan Statements
   Receiving bills for loans or HELOCs you didn’t take out is a major red flag.
2. Foreclosure Notices
   Notices threatening foreclosure, especially when your mortgage payments are current, could indicate title fraud.
3. Missing or Inaccurate Bills
   If bills stop arriving or contain incorrect information, such as a different account holder name, investigate immediately.
4. Stopped Automatic Payments
   Automatic payments for your mortgage or property taxes stopping unexpectedly may suggest someone tampered with your accounts.
5. Unfamiliar Credit Activity
   New accounts or inquiries on your credit report could signal identity theft and potentially home title fraud.
6. Suspicious Real Estate Activity
   Calls from real estate agents about selling or renting your home without your knowledge may indicate fraud.

How to Prevent Home Title Fraud

Although preventing home title fraud completely is challenging, these proactive steps can reduce your risk:

1. Keep Your Home Occupied or Monitored

Unoccupied homes are prime targets for fraudsters. Maintain the appearance of occupancy with routine yard work, mail collection, and timed lights.

2. Monitor Your Mail

Review all mail, especially bills, lender statements, and unexpected loan offers. Suspicious mail can be an early warning sign.

3. Watch Your Bank Statements

Check your statements frequently to spot unusual payments or the sudden halt of automatic deductions for your mortgage.

4. Monitor Your Credit

Services like ScoreSense and Smart Credit can help you track your credit for unfamiliar activity, such as new accounts or changes in your credit score. Staying informed is key to catching fraud early.

5. Check Property Records

Contact your town clerk periodically to ensure your property’s title remains unchanged. This extra step can confirm that no unauthorized transfers have occurred.

6. Consider Title Protection

Some companies offer title protection, also known as title lock insurance, to help safeguard your deed. However, be cautious and research providers thoroughly to avoid scams.

How to Report Home Title Fraud

If you suspect you’ve been a victim of home title fraud, act quickly. Here’s what you should do:

1. Notify Your Mortgage Lender
   Inform your lender immediately to stop further fraudulent activity.
2. Contact Other Lenders
   If you’ve received unfamiliar loan bills or foreclosure notices, alert those lenders as well.
3. Report the Fraud to Authorities
   File a report with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and your state attorney general’s office. Local authorities may also have specific protocols for handling title fraud.
4. File a Police Report
   A formal police report creates a paper trail and can support your case if legal action is needed.
5. Alert Credit Bureaus
   Place a fraud alert or credit freeze on your accounts through the major credit bureaus: TransUnion, Equifax, and Experian. These measures require creditors to verify your identity before approving new credit in your name.

The Bottom Line

Home title fraud is rare but potentially devastating. Recognizing the signs early and taking preventive measures can help safeguard your home and finances. Regularly monitoring your credit through services like ScoreSense and Smart Credit can provide additional protection by alerting you to suspicious activity.

Stay vigilant and proactive. By keeping close tabs on your property records, mail, bank statements, and credit, you’ll be better prepared to catch fraud early and take swift action to protect your most valuable asset: your home.

If you ever need expert assistance or guidance on your credit journey, don’t hesitate to reach out to the Nerds! Additionally, stay updated with the latest tips and information by following us on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok!